Local 2015 Good Beer Guide Entries & other Musings

So a couple of weeks late perhaps and yes, my first post since May I know, but I have been busy doing my part (as cellar manager) in trying to establish a new opening as a reputable ale and home cooked food venue in one of Sheffield’s suburbs. And as much fun as that has been it is time to look at the entries in this year’s Good Beer Guide.

So let’s start with the city itself. Well, not too much to report there with three venues going out and three more being voted in. Did I vote? No I didn’t get round to it as usual so it’s not just the blog my voice has been missing from. However, plenty of members clearly have voted and the results are in, published and sat in some of your bookcases.

The new entries in the guide this year are The Closed Shop, The Francis Newton and The Porter Brook. Now, on the face of it these are all pretty reasonable ale places. I have been in The Closed Shop a couple of times in the last 18 months and the beer range has always been good, but I have not been in enough to pass real comment. The Francis Newton is undoubtedly the nicest Spoons in Sheffield with its beer garden, car park and lack of reprobates. And it does usually have a good beer range but is it so much better than that of the Sheaf Island or the Huntsman? Even the Bankers Draft has been doing well with their beer choice recently which is good as it’s the nicest building Spoons have got in the city. In 2011 the Rawson Spring got in which I imagine is the year it opened. And lastly The Porter Brook, a good boozer, I’ve always like it even if it’s always been a little short on seats. I know it belongs to the evil Greene King but as The Ball in Crookes has shown, they do allow some of their pubs to stock an amount of local ales that is greater than their own.

So all very well and good in general you might say, but at what cost? Well it means that three places have been voted out of the Good Beer Guide. The Ship on Shalesmoor is no longer in but it has hardly been a mainstay anyway. It appeared in the 2012 and 2013 guides but was not in the 2011 edition, I’m not sure about earlier. However it has improved its beer range recently, even installing an extra pump. Considering its proximity to Kelham Island it was about time they took advantage although I appreciate it’s not a free house. And the Landlady is not in favour of tasters so that’s two pubs in the area with that policy as the Wellington started doing it last year. It is a policy I find particularly small minded and counterproductive for beer sales and in all the places I’ve visited around the country I don’t think I’ve ever been refused a taster. And if that is your policy then either the staff need to be extremely knowledgeable or there should be tasting notes on a board near the bar. It’s just good practice, simple as that.

Anyway, let’s not stray too far from the subject at hand. The second pub that is not in next year’s guide is The Cobden View in Crookes which has been in for the last few years. This is perhaps not entirely surprising. It is a lovely pub, friendly and cosy but it’s never had the best range of beers, lacking in guests as far as I’ve noticed. So while it was a solid local entry there is now more competition around the city for members to vote for. And perhaps the ‘bar’ has been raised too.

The last omission is the most surprising as it was a worthy entry for a number of years. The Old House is a welcome respite on Devonshire/Devonshire Street from the bars and chain pubs, providing six hand pulled beers, an impressive array of cocktails, and good quality home cooked food. There is a robust guest beer policy that fits around the in house True North Brewing Company, whose own beers have been steadily improving of late. But such is the fickle nature of the voting public even within a member orientated organisation. I’m sure enough people will continue to go the Old House to drink beer but it is a shame it has lost that badge of honour. The Forum Group, who own it, have two other venues in the Good Beer Guide; the York and the Broadfield, current jewel in the crown. It remains to be seen if the new opening in the Mosborough (The British Oak) will be voted in, but it is out there all by itself in terms of ale pubs and we know that clustering does help. As does the number of (voting) CAMRA members who live nearby. Also, it has only been open since the end of March and voting for the 2016 edition takes place before Christmas.

The Sheffield AMRA branch is also responsible for part of North Derbyshire too but there is no change there. The Red Lion at Litton, The Grouse Inn near Longshaw, The Anglers Rest at Millers Dale, The Cheshire Cheese in Hope, The Packhorse Inn at Little Longstone and The Three Stags Head near Wardlow all remaining in the guide. Also still included is the excellent Arkwright Arms in Duckmanton, The All Inn at Staveley, The Rutland Arms in Holmesfield and The Hare and Hounds in Barlow. But the big upset occurs in Dronfield. Recently granted its own sub branch it has seen both of the pubs in last year’s guide slip out. These were The Three Tuns, Spire Brewery’s tap and The Coach House a Thornbridge outlet close to Sheffield. Both were worthy of inclusion in my opinion but have now been replaced by The Travellers Rest at Apperknowle and The Cross Daggers in Coal Aston. We have been in the former and it was reasonable for beer selection if not revelatory. But then, a pub in its location is hardly going to be pursuing that. The other usurper is one I have not heard of never mind visited, but it is off the main road. According to What Pub The Cross Daggers has three regular beers (Farmers Blonde, Moonshine and Tetleys and one guest but on that evidence I don’t think it beats the Coach & Horses or the Three Tuns. Of course it is not all about beer choice, with beer condition a factor, but it is surely the main consideration given the title of the guide. We shall have to see what happens next year in this area.

None of the exiting pubs are to be blamed in my opinion as they have not changed their way of working to my knowledge. But as previously stated, there is increased competition and the standard is rising with almost every new opening or venture. I don’t think I blogged on GBG entries last year but I have noticed that Archer Road Beer Stop has not been in the guide since the 2013 edition and this will also be for the reasons stated above. That is also a shame as it was good to see a real ale off licence in the guide. But, once again, there is more competition in that area with a flurry of activity in the last year. Beer Central opened in the new market and hit the ground running with some excellent beer choices, local and from afar. I remarked that they could do with a bigger unit but they like their location in the market too much to move. The Hop Hideout is almost next to the Broadfield on Abbeydale road and is a tentative operation but again the research has been done and beer is available there that is not available elsewhere in the city. There’s also a good chance they’ll move to bigger premises soon and extend their opening hours. Further down Abbeydale Road is the Yorkshire supermarket Mr Pickles. What a great concept! And, even better, they sell bottled beer. Only from God’s Own County of course but the selection is still as rich as you’d expect. I was able to get pretty much all the Tour De France beers that the Yorkshire breweries made. Dave at Archer Road beer stop has upped his game in response, although he’ll always have his loyal customers like me. And even Mitchell’s responded by increasing their range; now being the only place in Sheffield to stock Titanic beers. Although the Plum Porter sadly remains elusive.

I decided not to limit myself to Sheffield when checking the entries against those of last year, mainly out of curiosity. My other half comes from Worksop and my sister moved to Chesterfield this year so I drink in these neighbouring districts on a fairly regular basis. There’s no change in Worksop or in any of the surrounding settlements as far as I can tell. The Grafton Hotel, the Mallard, the Station Hotel and the Shireoaks are still Worksop’s premier drinking establishments. And of course you can get real ale in the Liquorice Gardens, the obligatory Wetherspoons which sits in a most curious building. I would like to see the Anchor, which is Dukeries Brewery nominated tap, challenge the Shireoaks one year as I think it deserves an entry. Primarily an eating pub but there is a tap room to the right as you enter and a choice of around five ales and the odd guest beer if I recall correctly.

And so on to Chesterfield where the most heinous crime has been committed. When my sister and her partner moved there I told them the best pub for beer is the Chesterfield Arms. So how on earth has it been passed over for inclusion?! Well this can happen; it’s all down to members and herein lies the problem with the Good Beer Guide. For a lot of people it’s probably about proximity and reputation but that doesn’t mean that pubs not in the guide are not worthy of visiting. It is after all only a guide and not the definitive word on the subject. I think that is most likely impossible to achieve. We use it when visiting somewhere new as it’s the easiest way to find real ale. But take Leeds for example, one of our first crawls. We used the guide when we first went and we checked it on our second visit. But we still went back to places that featured in the guide of the previous year even if they were not in the current one, because we knew we could find good ale there. It is this knowledge gap that (for me) What Pub aims to fill. That and local blogs I suppose. The other change in Chesterfield is Spa Lane Vaults, one of the two Wetherspoons, but we’ve seen in Sheffield that these can flit in and out of the guide year to year. So the new ones that go in are both veterans of previous years; the Peacock in Brampton and the Market in the centre. Both decent pubs but neither have up to 16 beers on at a weekend like the Chesterfield Arms. Oh well, I would hope at least that the Chesterfield Ale House goes in the 2016 guide.

Keg Beer

So yes, I aim to be blogging a little more this year. Yes I know, it's May already and there's only been one post but I've changed jobs and life has generally got in the way. Beer has not got in the way though. Well, I suppose it has actually but I don't really mind that. It was good to meet Wee Beefy in person the other week even if our initial handshake had disastrous consequences for my colleagues drink, and the dryness of his crotch! Having a chat with him made me realise I need to be on here more, spouting my irrelevant thoughts about the beer world.

And so... kegged beer. Sorry if I just swore at you then but its rise on the bar cannot be denied no matter how you feel about it. I must admit I was less than enthused about the concept when I came across it but I am slowly being won over. Now as a member of CAMRA I am aware of course that their organisation is duty bound to have a problem with beer that comes out of a keg and is chilled to a greater extent than cask beer. After all it is the very foundation upon which they built their cause. So I therefore appreciate that many members will most likely shun keg beer on principle. And it is a fine principle but the times they are a-changing. CAMRA does its upmost to attract younger drinkers, in order to challenge the middle aged bearded man reputation which they have been saddled with. And yes, many different types of people drink and enjoy ale, real or otherwise. But middles aged bearded men in particular enjoy and drink ale. And the problem with kegged beer is that it is somehow a little bit sexier than cask beer and therefore is consumed largely (I suspect, from what I have observed) by younger drinkers.

Are CAMRA shooting themselves in the foot here? Well I'm not going to go that far but I will say that every organistion reaches a point where it has to move with the times or risk becoming obsolete. The church for instance. So we will just have to see how it all pans out; they certainly can't just ignore the trend. But I suppose kegged beer needs to have more going for it than simply being a trend before it gets acknowledgment.

So why have I come around to keg beer? Well... it's beer. Why would I ignore it? It may not be drawn by a hand pump from a horizontal vessel but to me it is still beer. Yes, I can hear the howls of derision as I type this but that it is my opinion as it stands at the moment. For me it means greater choice on the bar. But I will not call it real ale, we can have the debate about what should or shouldn't be real some other time. I don't mind that it is colder and fizzier, that makes it refreshing to me. It is fair to say that many ale drinkers (perhaps not the serious ones) will switch to lager on a hot sunny day (remember those?) and lager drinkers may switch to cider. Yes, some real ale drinkers will switch to real cider but they will be the serious ones. So perhaps some of these 'sunny switchers' will now switch to a kegged ale instead of a lager, And that's a win surely? One less person swigging Carling is definitely a good thing in my book. And as I've said before, it offers a greater choice. Many breweries now have a keg beer among their portfolio and so there is even more to choose from. Now, not everything produced is going to be original and great but the same can be said of cask beer. If breweries are simply kegging one of their cask beers then I may frown slightly as that is rather a case of jumping lazily on the beer wagon. But it would be a start at least and there are plenty of brewers who take keg beers seriously and are designing beers specifically for that medium. Abbeydale for instance; their Pale Ale #2 appears to be a roaring success, and with good reason. I think it also allows for more experimentation with novelty beers, especially higher percentage ones as kegged beer should last longer (so I am led to believe).

But anyway, I have no more time to expand my reasoning as I'm off to a wedding reception where I hope to find some ale, real or otherwise. So next time you see a kegged beer from a reputable brewery, give it a shot. You just might surprise yourself.

 

2013 - The Stats

Now, like every good beer ticker we have analysed the results of last year to see what our drinking habits were. Well maybe not every good beer ticker as we operate by iPhone note when out and about and it all ends up on a spreadsheet. (I am, according to a colleague, a digital ticker and I quite like that!) Yes, yes I can hear your snorts of derision from here, but if real ale is truly an interest then I think you should be interested in what you drink, where you drink it and how much of it you drink. But yes, I have always been one for lists I'll give you that.

So... to the results. 

Most Popular Beers

1. Moonshine 4.3%,  Abbeydale - 24 (Surprised us! Because we generally seek out new ales. But that's the ubiquitous part. Not that it isn't a damn fine beer mind you)
2. Acorn Blonde 4.0%/Easy Rider 4.3%, Kelham Island - 19 (Both are regulars at my local)
3. Deception 4.1%, Abbeydale - 18
4. Blue Moon 6.0%, Pictish - 15
5. First Blonde 4.0%, True North - 12

Most Drunk Local Brewery

1. Abbeydale - 80
2. Acorn - 53
3. Kelham Island - 42
4. Bradfield - 34
5. Thornbridge/Welbeck Abbey - 27

Most Drunk Guest Brewery

1. Pictish - 67
2. Castle Rock/Milestone/Ossett - 21
3. Saltaire - 18
4. Dancing Duck/Great Heck/Phoenix - 16
5. Rudgate - 14

Most Visited Public House

1. The Sheaf View - 82 (It is my local after all!)
2. The Broadfield - 13
3. The Fat Cat -12
4. The Harlequin/Shakespeare's - 11
5. The Red Deer - 9

No, of beer festivals visited; 11

Highlights being; Great British Beer Festival, Bradford (held in Saltaire), Barrow Hill, Nottingham.

Notes

• Counts include halves and pints consumed; how often we have chosen a beer or brewery, not the amount consumed
• The results are definitely a reflection of what we like but are also indicative of how ubiquitous a brewery or beer is, or how narrow the choice may be
• 'Local' includes all South Yorkshire, North Derbyshire and North Nottinghamshire breweries
• 'Guest Brewery' refers to all breweries that are not local but are found and drunk often enough to be counted

This year there will be more stouts and porters as we have recently got into them properly, and our tastes have changed so I doubt Pictish will be top gust brewery next year.

Restating the Purpose

Yes I know, it has been too long between posts to really call myself a blogger these days. But fear not, ale is still being drunk, in Sheffield, at home and in various other places around England. Yes, yes, I am really behind with my write ups but I still aim to catch up and there are a couple that can be added to the blog since Beer Matters don't seem to want to push them. I have many things to muse on (over?) though if you will.

But hey ho (and ho ho ho far too soon) we are looking forward to going around Newark the week before Christmas and checking out a micropub, which is an excellent concept and fast catching on. Just to recpap (and remind myself how far behind I am) we have toured the Good Beer Guide pubs in Newcastle, Durham, Scarborough, York, Wakefield, Leeds, Halifax and Sowerby Bridge, Todmorden, Rochdale, Manchester, Liverpool, Rotherham, Worksop, Chesterfield, Derby, Lincoln, Leicester, Nottingham, Burton (a cool but weird place), Birmingham, Bristol, Bath, Bradford-Upon-Avon and parts of London. And we can tell you that Sheffield is one of the cheapest places to drink real ale, despite what you might think (perhaps you're drinking in the wrong places!). 

I started this blog to charter the real ale scene in Sheffield and felt some obligation to champion it since I picked such an ambitious name (oops). However I also found a new purpose by touring the country; the search for a comparable ale crawl to our own famous Kelham Island scene. And there are some that do hold up to scrutiny to be fair; Manchester's Northgate Quarter, Newcastle, Wakefield (yes really) and Chesterfield (dee da accusations none withstanding). And there are some that fall short; Birmingham, Lincoln and Burton. Birmingham was too busy with itself and too hip to worry about an ale scene. Lincoln had wonderful pubs but no local breweries (Marston's dominated) and Burton was just an odd place. It's a brewery surrounded by a town but there's only two major breweries left there; one of which does thankfully see cask ale as a just cause (Marston's) and the other of which it is a byproduct (Coors/Worthington's) of countless takeovers and downsizing. Bizarre that Coors now own the Bass site but Bass ale is now brewed by one time rival Marston's. At least part of the site is now the National Brewery Centre which every self respecting beer drinker should visit as a matter of course.

But I digress, tis the season to be jolly (like we need an excuse) and Christmas beers are starting to appear. But I can't bring myself to buy any yet. Maybe next week. But at least I have got into stouts and porters which has broadened my pallet at last. I'll be posting soon about bottled beer in Sheffield, something I have long since been meaning to post about. But even more pertinent now with these new businesses...

Real Ale Venue Categories

I thought it would be interesting to try and come up with a series of classifications for establishments that sell real ale. It is not an exhaustive list and some places may fit into more than one category.

Even though there are many different types of places that sell ale I have notice there are some common themes. It is more about the operation itself and the products sold than the building, for instance; whether it is a heritage pub is irrelevant it is more abut the modus operandi.

 

The Pure Ale Pub

Freehouses that focus only on selling real ale, with no food or entertainment; no games machines, no music, only continental lagers (bottled and draught) and quality bar snacks. Often with a décor that emphasizes wood and has modest size tables in order to increase seating space. More of a traditional pub it is less likely to open late and will often have a welcoming outside drinking area. Could be accused of being ‘old man’ pubs but this is frequently not the case and is becoming less so as real ale consumption continues to rise.

Examples: The Sheaf View, The Wellington, The Blue Bell in York, The Wellington in Birmingham, Strugglers Inn, Lincoln, The Cornubia in Bristol.

The Food/Entertainment Ale Pub

Freehouses, tenancies and managed houses that have many if not all of the features of the pure ale pub but also serve food or host live music nights. They may also play music and have games machines. Why the distinction between those that serve food and those that don’t? Well sometimes you just want to go for a drink and don’t wish to sit next to some one eating, particularly if you are a dog owner. It makes proceedings slightly more formal and also means there is a distraction from the selling of ale. Those pubs that don’t serve food will sell more beer and therefore take it very seriously as it’s all they do. Pubs that have live music also have a distraction and a very imposing one if you are looking for a quiet drink, they will also often serve later.

Examples: The Kelham Island Tavern, The White Lion, The Broadfield, The Bridge in Newcastle, Whitelocks in Leeds, The Brunswick in Derby.

Ale Bar

Definitely not a pub but an establishment that sells ale usually in the commercial part of a city or town centre. They will often have late opening hours, not be in a typical pub building or a much modified one at least, and play music sometimes by a DJ. They could also do food or live music and other alcoholic drinks such as Alco pops, wine and cocktails.

Examples: The Old House, Henry’s, Dada, The Hop, The Beer Parlour in Manchester, North Bar in Leeds, any Wetherspoons.

Affiliated Pub/Bars

These are pubs or bars that are connected to a brewery, either a micro, regional or national, so not a completely separate classification as such, but worth mentioning. The former sells beers from the affiliated brewery at a discounted price but the operation could be any of the previous classifications. Take away beer from the brewery and other merchandise is also sometimes available. The latter two largely work in the same way but the beer price may vary depending on the brand or location. The idea is there always a place where you can get most of the range from a brewery, at least with the former.

Examples: The Rising Sun, The Fat Cat, The Nags Head, The Rose & Crown in Chesterfield, The Fox & Newt in Leeds, Marble Arch in Manchester.

Ale Promoters

These are pubs/bars that are not defined by real ale but sell it alongside other beverages as they recognise there is a market for it. There will typically not be more than three hand pumps or as few as one. There will be a balance across all beverage types but this does not mean the ale will not be well looked after, and there would still be consideration for an entry in the Good Beer Guide should it receive enough votes.

Examples: The Wick at Both Ends, The Bessemer, The Crown on London rd.

Micro Pubs

The micro pub concept is really taking off around the country. Low start up and running costs are an attractive prospect for the real ale enthusiast seeking to be more involved in the ale scene. Typically the size of a terraced shop unit they will have a handful of tables, will have limited opening hours, only ever serve guest ales mainly from micro breweries and be run by one or maybe two people. There will most likely be no music or food, unless prepared off site, in order to keep licensing costs down, although snacks will be present. There are two micro pubs in neighbouring Chesterfield, both also great places to buy bottled beer, the Beer Parlour in Whittington Moor and the Real Ale Corner in  Brampton. Bizarrely, Sheffield does not have one although I am told that a couple of businessmen are looking at the possibility of setting up one in Broomhill.

All in all I think it is good that real ale drinkers have different types of surroundings in which to drink, variety is the spice of life and there are many different types of ale drinkers. But I will not be attempting to classify those anytime soon as it would be gargantuan task of diplomacy!

Beer Gardens of Sheffield

So which real ale pub in Sheffield has the best beer garden? I’m not the first local blogger to ask that question but seeing as we seem to be having some decent weather I thought I’d throw my opinion out there.

A few years ago I would have, without hesitation, agreed whole heartedly with gettothepub.com and say the Kelham Island Tavern. L shaped with plenty of seats, you sit among an urban jungle with actual vegetation. Sitting in that garden you would not think you were in the heart of an industrial wasteland. As pure escapism goes it’s hard to beat.

The Tavern is definitely still up there but there are now other outside drinking areas in which I’m also very happy to drink. The Fat Cat also has a top notch beer garden with the added features of a two covered areas, heat lamps and an equally cosy atmosphere. It wasn’t long ago when you could spot the old pub sign leaning against a wall, from the days when the Cat was known as the Alma after the road upon which it resides.

Staying around Kelham Island for now; the Riverside has a recently expanded beer garden although it is more functional than cosy in comparison to the last two discussed. However it does (as you would rather expect from its name) have a riverside beer garden, a surprisingly rare occurrence given the five rivers that flow through our fair city. There are only two that I can think of, both on the Don. The Riverside also has an outdoor shelter and has plenty of tables and seats.

The Gardeners Rest has the other riverside beer garden and is certainly a favourite of mine. Not that many seats but it does have a great atmosphere, with a few quirky touches, and has a better river view than the Riverside. Measures have been taken to boost the flood defences too in order to prevent a disaster on the 2007 scale, which saw them out of action for about 2 years. Being a little further out it does not get as busy as the gardens of the previous 3.

The Wellington is another of my favourites and while limited in size it more than makes up for it in character. There is a toilet seat, a traffic light and numerous signs pinned to the walls and fences. Having a covered area and ashtrays on the wall of the gents toilets also limits how much smoke gets into the garden. There is also a table around the other side of the toilet block which is often missed unless you squeeze past the owners car.

I am also quite partial to the drinking area around the conservatory of the Hillsborough. You could argue it is not very exciting but given its elevated rear position it offers a sense of privacy and some good views towards the city centre. The conservatory itself has 3 doors that can be opened meaning you still retain an element of the outside if you sit inside.

A recent favourite is the space behind the New Barrack Tavern which is often largely covered and provides plenty of vegetation as decoration. There is also a road sign that is a nod to a defunct nearby brewery; High House. And heading back towards town and up the hill there is the Blake which threatens to give you excellent views towards the city centre but sadly can’t, in respect to its neighbours. All decked out and with plenty of tables it is also not short on natural influences, which are due to be extended in the near future. There is also a sheltered smoking area near the back door and you can always perch on the back wall if all the tables are taken.

I must admit that I’m not sure what other beer gardens are on offer in the Crookes/Walkley area but I will be heading there soon so will investigate!

Moving into the city centre I would have to agree with gettothepub.com again; the Rutland Arms has the best beer garden there. A decent amount of seats and the level of vegetation serves to partly block out the city, although it’s hard to eliminate the roar of buses entering and leaving the bus station. And I’m told it’s no longer a sun trap since the Sheffield Hallam building across the lane was completed. But that wouldn’t bother me!

The Red Lion only had two tables at the front last time I went in but it is still a pleasant place to sit if you can. And the last time I drove past they had claimed some of the newly paved area near the front door with a couple more tables. It is not unpleasant to sit outside the Roebuck Tavern and watch the world go by, although I preferred doing the same outside the Yorkshire Grey (sob).

Heading out of the centre you have the University Arms which has a very nice place to drink beer outside. Plenty of space, trees and plenty of benches to sit at, all on grass too, but also suffers a little from being near a main road. Further up the hill and Sheffield’s nicest Wetherspoons is also the only one with a beer garden. The Francis Newton has benches around the building as well as a separate terrace on which you can eat. It’s a shame there are no seats in the garden, but then it is on a slope and I’m not sure if they’re allowed to do anything with it.

Shifting South East and you have the Sheaf View my celebrated local. Raised decking at the back and a grass bank with trees down the side make for pleasant surroundings. Further covered seating is round the side and mainly occupied by smokers. The beer garden is also very accessible with external doors in both sides of the pub and a path to the front.

I have always been quite fond of the White Lion’s beer garden having spent quite a lot of time there a few years ago. Cosy and interesting; spanning 3 levels it also has a shelter for smokers. If I recall there is some shrubbery and it certainly feels private.

I used to go to Carbrook Hall in days gone by as that has an excellent beer garden, but I’ve no idea if they currently have any real ale on. But that is all I can think to recommend in Sheffield without further investigation. It can generally be accepted that pubs further out in the suburbs probably have decent outside areas, due to lower density and possibly more greenery.

Of course you can always head out into the Peak District. The Millstone has plenty of tables outside the pub and a few more across the road at the edge of the car park. There are goats and micro pigs to amuse you but it’s a shame that trees obscure what would be a fine view. The Grouse has a modest sized terrace at the side of the building but does offer some good views. But if a view is what you want then you can’t beat the Barrel just outside Foolow, with it’s commanding ridge top position. Apparently on a clear day you can see 5 counties from that hill. There are some tables on a terrace at the front, some benches in front of the car parking spaces along the ridge, and you can sit on the grass bank at the side of the pub. Either way there are stunning views across a good portion of Derbyshire and if I recall there are 3 or 4 hand pumps dispensing real ale. If I could only go to one place it might well be there!

Your local - Favourite nearby pub or literally the nearest pub?

Being a card carrying CAMRA member (I do travel the country and you never know where there might be a discount!) I receive the seasonal publication Beer. In this year’s Spring issue there was an interesting for and against argument as to whether one's local is the nearest pub to where you live or the one that you visit the most because it ticks all your boxes, and is also near to your home. 

I myself have long considered this quandary and got around the problem by using the distinction of 'geographical local' and 'local'. The former being the closet pub to where I live and the latter being my regular drinking hole of choice. I have had a good few locals in my time and drank beer at all of them although I am a rather late convert to real ale, I have to admit. I remember drinking Trophy in my first local which was a Whitbread pub, remember those? I always thought it was funny that it stood almost opposite a Bass pub. Those were the days when you could walk into a pub and tell which brewery owned it, from what was on the bar, lagers and all. I suppose that is still possible now to some degree, only it’s now Greene King and Marston’s to distinguish between, amongst various regional breweries. Anyway, I digress from my digression; Trophy was a truly a lifeless, bland beverage and I'm somewhat pleased that it has completely disappeared. But at least it was weaker (and cheaper) than Pedigree which was the hand pull and as young 'un's we couldn't drink much of that in a session, and I didn't like Boddingtons which was the other (electric) alternative. 

Now that pub, (my first local; the Cross Scythes in Totley) was my favourite pub in the area and also the nearest to where I lived. It had pool, snooker, a juke box, sold pork scratchings and had character to spare (wallpaper peeling off the walls), what else did a teenage boy need? A local borne of proximity was also true of my next home, even though I was only there for 10 months, which was regrettable as the nearest boozer was the Rising Sun in Nether Green. I used to pop in there with my compatriot from the Totley days and play darts, and to be fair that is why I frequented it; it had a dart board. Oh the horror. I’d like to think that we did sample a few different ales but I can’t be sure. Not that I have anything against darts you understand, I just lament a missed opportunity to really appreciate a fine ale pub.

In the pursuit of darts, ale and downtime John and I have a long list of ours under our belt that acted as our local for our intents and purposes. Two other pubs were regularly visited in Totley; the Fleur De Lys (the former bass pub, turncoat! Although I later went on the work for Bass Leisure Retail/Six Continents/Mitchells & Butler), where we learned to appreciate Stones and the Shepley Spitfire which at that point was still a Kimberley Ales pub. This was before Greene King bought them and continued to cement their reputation as the bully of the brewery industry. We also used to visit the Yellow Lion in Apperknowle (the asshole of North Derbyshire, although this was before I visited Clay Cross), the Market in High Green, the Arundel near Ecclesfield (now an Indian restaurant), the Travellers Rest in Ecclesfield (Tetley’s Smooth, nooooo!) and the White Lion on London Rd.

I have just moved from Highfields where I lived for almost 6 years but my first local there was the newly refurbished Earl of Arundel and Surrey. That didn’t last long as landlords came and went and then completely gave up. From there I stuck with the White Lion for a good while, sinking many pints of hand pulled Tetley’s. For some reason the Sheaf View wasn’t quite on my radar at that point and I also occasionally dipped into the Golden Lion on Alderson Road, a pub that had never heard of real ale. But after a while good sense prevailed and the Sheaf stuck as my local, and it is contestable if that was actually the nearest pub as I lived about halfway between there and the Cremorne. But either way it is the place that will always be my local at heart and I am loathe to move too far away from it! Crazy perhaps, but sometimes that is the power of the local on a dedicated beer lover.

I am now living (as of last weekend) in the limbo area between Heeley and Meersbrook. So happily the Sheaf View is still nearby but it is not the closest pub anymore. But there’s no way in hell I am going to call the Old Crown my local as it hasn’t seen a hand pump since about 1968. Well, maybe 1999 as it was a Wards pub after all. Still, the White Lion is the nearest decent ale pub and that suits me just fine. But I guess I do subscribe to the view that my local is the nearest great pub that I don’t hesitate to visit with any excuse.

It is very subjective though; I used to call in the Yorkshire Grey (may it rest in peace) a lot and often referred to it as my ‘local in town’, as it was where I always ended up. Black Sheep, pool table, video games, food, outside beer garden and a mixed clientele meant that it covered a lot of ground. I don’t really have a local in town though although I suppose frequency might dictate that it’s the Red Deer. Even though the Harlequin probably isn’t my most visited Kelham Island pub, I would still say it’s my local in that area as I now meet John there once a month (darts are no longer thrown even though it does have a darts board!) and I got with my other half Pip there and so where else could I propose to her last summer?!

So ends my thoughts on the ‘local’ issue although I seem to have almost detailed my entire beer history, sorry!